Home

SiriKit custom intent tutorial

Custom Intents - Siri - Human Interface Guidelines - Apple Develope

Custom Intents. If your app lets people perform an everyday task that doesn't fit into any of the SiriKit domains, you can create a custom intent to represent it (see System Intents for a list of domains). You can also use a custom or system intent to support a shortcut, which gives people a quick way to initiate frequently performed actions by speaking a simple phrase or accepting a. Custom Intents with SiriKit on iOS 12. Yesterday was the start of WWDC 2018 and one new feature in iOS 12 caught my attention amongst the many that were demonstrated: The demo was part of the new Shortcuts system and showed that apps could reveal some functionality to Siri, in this case the Tile app being able to search for your keys Customizing the SiriKit Intent User Interface. the configureView method allows each section of the default user interface to be replaced with custom content and view layout. SiriKit considers the default layout to be a vertical stack in which each row is represented by a parameter. A SwiftUI SiriKit Tutorial. Next Next post:. In 2018 at the Worldwide Developer Conference Apple announced the new app Siri Shortcuts, which allows iOS users to create custom voice commands for their apps. A year later at the Worldwide Developer Conference 2019, Apple has given Sirikit more privileges to ask the user for input parameters in custom intent with Siri Dialog This is where SiriKit with Siri Shortcuts comes in. I want to preface this post with the following. I felt there is a need for a more simple and yet more concise look at how to setup a Siri for your app using Intents which is the truly powerful way to extend your app using new SiriKit features introduced in WWDC18

I know siri provides limited Intents and we have to add our app to domain to be able take input from siri. But I would like to create my own intent for the users to access my app via siri. I coul.. When considering SiriKit adoption, look at the Domains and their Intents to see which ones make sense for your app. An Intent often has parameters: when sending a message, to whom it is addressed; when making a reservation, what restaurant and for how many people. Consequently, implementing an Intent has you performing three steps I have the problem, that Siri always responses with the english version of my intents. I have create a demo project to seperate out the relevant code: I have 3 targets in my project: The Developers can adopt SiriKit to enable their apps to interact with Siri. In this tutorial, Jayven will walk you through the SiriKit and how you can build an app that communicates with Siri. At the time of this writing, SiriKit is limited to certain kinds of apps. In less than 7 hours, Apple will kick off this year's WWDC Sirikit custom intent tutorial. Once the keynote was over and the documentation went live, I had a dig through and was intrigued to find a new custom intent within SiriKit exposed as INObject. This is paired with a full demo app in the form of Soup Chef that shows how you can create these custom intents and use them as shortcuts for Siri

Custom Intents with SiriKit on iOS 12 - Ben Dodso

  1. SiriKit, ShortCut, intent. Contribute to ebPark9511/SiriKit development by creating an account on GitHub
  2. Custom Intents with SiriKit on iOS 12 Yesterday was the start of WWDC 2018 and one new feature in iOS 12 caught my attention amongst the many that were demonstrated: The demo was part of the new Shortcuts system and showed that apps could reveal some functionality to Siri, in this case the Tile app being able to search for your keys
  3. In this tutorial you will learn how to get SiriKit working in your iOS App! To learn more about how SiriKit works behind the scenes, check out this article!. Requirements: Xcode 8, Swift 3 Project (this is what the tutorial is built on). Part 1. Getting a quick and simple demo running Create & setup iOS app. Create a new 'Single View Application' Xcode Project
  4. Siri Shortcut Tutorial using Custom Intent, Here I am going to go through the process of adding a custom Siri Shortcut. As before to use SiriKit we need an Intent App Extension to our app. Handle the Intents using the IntentHandling protocol auto-generated by Xcode. should include the shared framework in Linked Frameworks and Libraries
  5. SiriKit Custom Intents parameters and shortcuts I'm trying to figure out how to define and create shortcuts using the Custom Intents in iOS12. I want to create a shortcut so that a user can add a task to my app and give it a name (and other parameters in the future)

Customizing the SiriKit Intent User Interface - Answertopi

46.10. Configuring the SiriKit Intent Definition File. Locate the Intents.intentdefinition file and select it to load it into the editor. The file is currently empty, so add a new intent by clicking on the '+' button in the lower left-hand corner of the editor panel and selecting the New Intent menu option: In the Custom Intents panel. As before to use SiriKit we need an Intent App Extension to our app. This extension will handle the shortcuts which will run in the background. In this tutorial, we'll focus on donating shortcuts using Intents. Intents. Intents are a framework used to define the type of requests and handle the responses from Siri Step-by-step tutorial. Let's start with implementing voice commands using SiriKit to start and finish a workout in our fitness app. Step 1. Integrate SiriKit. Step 1.1. Create an Intents Extension target and implement a handler to start a workout. First of all, we need to create a target of the Intents Extension type

This SiriKit tutorial was taken from Chapter 6 of iOS 10 by Tutorials, which also covers the new changes in Swift 3, source editor extensions, Core Data updates, photography updates, search integration and all the other new, shiny APIs in iOS 10. You'll definitely enjoy the other 13 chapters and 300+ pages in the book SiriKit Tutorial. Apple has introduced the much awaited SiriKit in iOS 10. For information on how to implement your handlers, see Resolving and Handling Intents. Add the custom source files that you need to perform the tasks for any supported intents Intents are a framework used to define the type of requests and handle the responses from Siri. To create shortcuts you need to use the following: Intents App Extension - These receive the requests from SiriKit and perform the actions. Intents UI Extension - These are optional if you want to create a custom UI that would be displayed in Siri Busca trabajos relacionados con Sirikit custom intent tutorial o contrata en el mercado de freelancing más grande del mundo con más de 19m de trabajos. Es gratis registrarse y presentar tus propuestas laborales

I implemented two Custom Intents with Sirikit in my iOS app. When I was developing them I had iOS 13.3 installed in my iphone and one of my intents has a Siri Dialog prompt asking for the value of one parameter. All the app is translated to english and spanish and the custom intent worked nicely in both languages SiriKit's aim is to blur the boundaries between apps through a consistent conversational user experience that enables apps to remain intuitive, functional and engaging through pre-defined intents and domains. This tutorial will help you apply best practices to create intuitive conversational design user experiences without visual cues A simple, straight-forward, step-by-step guide to implementing iOS 12 Siri Shortcuts using Objective-C. I noticed that the documentation for integrating the new iOS Shortcuts API is very sparse. After a lot of trial and error, combined with reading the official docs and various tutorials and forum threads, I managed to get everything to work Siri Shortcut Tutorial using Custom Intent | by David Wu Siri & iOS 10 Apps Tutorial in Swift 3 Part 2 | Jameson Quave. Siri - Apple Developer. SiriKit Tutorial for iOS | raywenderlich.com. Learn how to integrate Siri with your app thanks to Apple Create SiriKit Extensions in iOS 10

IOS 13 Custom Intent With Siri Dialog by Karim Awd Better Programmin

If your app doesn't fit within the current intents, then you can't use SiriKit, and there's nothing you can do. Even if your app does fit, you can't control all of the words Siri says or understands; so, if you have a particular way of talking about things in your app, you can't always teach that to Siri I'm trying to figure out how to define and create shortcuts using the Custom Intents in iOS12. I want to create a shortcut so that a user can add a task to my app and give it a name (and other parameters in the future). For e.g. just say to Siri 'Add Task with name 'Pick up laundry''. Here is how I.. SiriKit Intents. Each domain allows a predefined set of tasks, or intents, to be requested by the user for fulfillment by an app. An intent represents a specific task of which Siri is aware and for which SiriKit expects an integrated iOS app to be able to perform Siri Shortcut is a new API that Apple introduced in iOS 12 built on top of SiriKit framework. It provides ways for developer to provide custom shortcut to the activities that the user often used within the app. In this article, I would like to provide a simple example on how we can use Siri Shortcut to perform search on upcoming movies using The Movie DB API

SiriKit - How to add Siri Shortcut with Intent to your app — Ramdan Korkeli

  1. In this tutorial, we've learned about in-app intent handling, how to output custom types from our Shortcut action and how to add images and subtitles to be displayed in lists. We've also seen how it's posssible to handle intents from the new SwiftUI app protocol on iOS14
  2. By doing this steps, two new targets (Intents Extension and UI Extension) are created, and by default they contain Workout Intent code. For different types of Siri requests, see Remarks. Note. Anytime you want to debug your extension, just select the Intent scheme from the available schemes. Note. You can't test SiriKit apps in the Simulator
  3. Registering custom terms provides Siri with the hints it needs to apply those terms appropriately to the corresponding intent objects. You may register only specific types of custom terms, such as the name of a contact, the name of a user's workout, a custom tag applied to a photo, or a user-specific payment type

ios - How do I create custom intent in siri - Stack Overflo

In the last part of this tutorial, I am going to show you how you can customize the user interface that Siri displays. First of all, remember to set the correct intent class that you want to handle in the Info.plist of the ExtensionUI, as we did in the previous section SiriKit. Apps adopt SiriKit by building an extension that communicates with Siri, even when your app isn't running. The extension registers with specific domains and intents that it can handle. Siri handles all of the user interaction, including the voice and natural language recognition, and works with your extension to get information and handle user requests

We're obviously not working with photos, but movies, so take this app as a tutorial only. Hopefully, your app will fit into one of the supported categories so you can use Siri with your app. Conclusion. A long time ago I wrote an article on voice commands and text to speech. Siri is nothing like it. SiriKit has a specific purpose and is quite. The configuration for an app lives in a SiriKit Intent Definition File, so we'll start off by adding a new intent definition file to our workspace. We'll need to make sure we add this file to both the App and the Widget Extension targets, otherwise this will not build and run properly. Next, we'll create a custom intent for our configuration In this tutorial, we'll be discussing how to use Siri capabilities in iOS Apps. We'll be creating our own ios application shortcut through which Siri would tell us the Latest tutorial released on Journaldev With the release of Siri Shortcuts in iOS 12, this is no longer the case. Now, you can create custom intents to represent any domain, and you can expose your app's services directly to Siri. In this tutorial, you'll learn how to use these new shortcuts APIs to integrate Siri into a writing app. Getting Started We use SiriKit custom intent to define these configuration properties. Previously we have not selected the Include Configuration Intent checkbox and by default the StaticConfiguration for our wallet widget is used. To initialize the configuration, we have to supply the following information: Kind: A string that identifies the widget

SiriKit Part 1: Hey Siri, How Do I Get Started? - Digital product development agency

To create an intent-based Widget, we first need a Siri intent. Inside your Widget Extensions, add a SiriKit Intent Definition File. To allow the user to see the commits of any repo or branch, let's create a LastCommitIntent that supports the account, repo and branch properties. Make sure to also tick the Intent is eliglible for Widgets box Phrases contain exact sirikit intent from credible sources. EXACT : Related keywords of sirikit intent from credible sources. sirikit intent. sirikit custom intentions signs. sirikit. sirikitye. sirikitiya. sirikit appeal. sirikit height. sirikit intent. sirikit xamarin. sirikit reservoir. sirikit tutorial. sirikit valentin.

ios - SiriKit: Custom Intents - localization problem - Stack Overflo

  1. SiriKit provides an option to the apps to display their custom ui while the user uses Siri to interact with the apps, we will not be covering the custom UI option in this tutorial. Lastly to get everything done click Finish. Then Xcode will ask you to activate the SiriChatIntentExtension scheme, click Activate to do that
  2. Siri tutorial Siri Personal Update: How to request your personalized . Hey Siri, daily briefing! Any of the above, or some such, will do the trick. Siri will first read you the weather forecast for the day. Next, you'll hear about any appointments that are on your calendar, followed by the current travel time and traffic conditions to any of the places Siri knows you're going toda
  3. This is based on a SiriKit intent definition file. To create one, add a file (through the top bar or a right-click) and search for SiriKit Intent Definition File. let's create our first custom intent. The Ultimate Symfony Tutorial on Internationalization. arrow_back arrow_forward
  4. g the tasks associated with any intents
  5. Developing Custom Shortcuts ‍ Along with the Siri Shortcuts dashboard, Siri also has a new Intent API available via SiriKit. This new API allows developers to create custom voice prompts that can be recognized by Siri to take actions in your application
  6. Intent Definition. Next, we define our custom intent with the SiriKit Intent Definition File. From File → New, select SiriKit Intent Definition File Click on the + button as shown and give it any name you want. Choose the category that best describes your intentions, then add a description

Intent definition files automatically create custom classes related to your custom intent. iOS Tutorial From the course this will come up as SiriKit Intent Definition File The list of application types (or intent domains, as Apple refers to them) can be found in the SiriKit documentation. Before we dive into creating our own Siri integration, it's worth clarifying. Intent configurations allow user-configurable properties using SiriKit's custom intents to define properties. This app will use a static configuration, as custom intents are not needed. An intent configuration would be more appropriate for a weather app where the user can enter their zip code 41.4 SiriKit Intents : 41.5 How SiriKit Integration Works : 41.6 Resolving Intent Parameters : 41.7 The Confirm Method : 41.8 The Handle Method : 41.9 Custom Vocabulary : 41.10 The Siri User Interface : 41.11 Summar Internationalisation issue with Sirikit Custom Intents & iOS 13.4.1 I implemented two Custom Intents with Sirikit in my iOS app. When I was developing them I had iOS 13.3 installed in my iphone and one of my intents has a Siri Dialog prompt asking for the value of one.

A Beginner's Guide to SiriKit in Swift AppCod

In this blog, we give you the step by step tutorial on how you can build a mobile widget with Apple's WidgetKit and Adobe Experience Platform Mobile SDKs. With the launch of iOS 14, Apple ha You can add your own custom You'll find more information on that in the Intents UI Guide. Examples and Tutorials . Here's a list of some more in-depth tutorials and samples diving into SiriKit.

SiriKit custom intent linking error on Xcode 1

Adding support of SiriKit in your app is as simple as Wait, nothing is that simple! In this post, you won't actually find a How to do it tutorial. It would be too long and would only be copying what Apple already provides with this video and this sample code.Instead, you will discover what it has meant to make this feature work in Deezer's iOS app Parameters in SiriKit custom intents & Fine-grained Shortcut integration (apps provide blocks): Parameters are definitely in and I believe (from the SOTU demos) that the Shortcuts app can directly call into intents with parameters, thus enabling more fine-grained interactions. This is great news, and even if you don't think Siri as a voice-assistant would be useful for your app, you should.

GitHub - ebPark9511/SiriKit: SiriKit, ShortCut, inten

  1. 阐述最近研究了一下SiriKit,感觉有点意思,记录并与大家探讨一下。工欲善其事必先利其器,在研究SiriKit模块时苹果官方介绍通篇充斥着Intent、Resolve、Confirm等词汇,让英语未过六级的我感到无比吃力。感觉词汇还是有必要给大家介绍一下,顺便统一单词说法以便大家能够看懂后续内容
  2. 4. An Introduction to Xcode 12 Playgrounds; 4.1 What is a Playground? 4.2 Creating a New Playground; 4.3 A Swift Playground Example; 4.4 Viewing Results; 4.5 Adding Rich Text Comments; 4.6 Working with Playground Pages; 4.7 Working with SwiftUI and Live View in Playground
  3. Get More Siri Shortcuts. If you want more wonderful Siri Shortcuts to enhance your workflow and even automate things, there are several places where you can get a collection of shortcuts. Below are the links to websites that create and maintain a library of awesome Siri Shortcuts: MacStories Shortcuts Archive; Matthew Cassinelli's Shortcut Library

Custom Intents with SiriKit on iOS 12 Laptrinh

  1. Create SiriKit Intent Definition File. Next, create a new File and use SiriKit Intent Definition File as the template. Click on the File to open the Intent Editor. Within this editor, we can create our custom intents and response. It will also generate the classes for our targets, in this case the app and the extensions we will create later
  2. SiriKit was created for developers in iOS 10. However, there were, and still are, a limited number of intent domains with which you can integrate an app. An intent domain is simply a category of app that can take advantage of Siri. With the release of iOS 11, a few new domains are being made available
  3. Intents Extensions. Our app interacts with Siri through an Intents extension. This extension does the job of retrieving the responses from Siri, identifying missing parameters, and supplying the results of our intent. We'll be adding a new Intents extension target to our project shortly, but first there are a few things we need to do before.
  4. SiriKit has two different types of app extensions: * Required extension. Intents extension receives intent objects from the system and performs the associated tasks. Intents extension is the basis of SiriKit and supports one or more intents, runs.
  5. In this tutorial, we will use right click and select New File > Add SiriKit Intent Defnition File. When the user logs in successfully in the main application, you can generate in the server a custom token and store it in NSUserDefaults. The shorcut can use this token to handle a challenge
  6. To create an intent-based widget, we first need a Siri Intent. Inside your widget extensions, add a SiriKit Intent Definition File. To allow the user to see the commits of any repo or branch, let's create a LastCommitIntent that supports the account, repo, and branch properties. Make sure to also tick the Intent is eligible for widgets box

Used when integrating an app with the SiriKit framework, these extensions are used to define the actions to be performed in response to voice commands using Siri. SiriKit integration and intents extensions are covered in the An Introduction to SiriKit , An iOS 10 Example SiriKit Messaging Extension and An iOS 10 SiriKit Photo Search Tutorial chapters of this book Once the keynote was over and the documentation went live, I had a dig through and was intrigued to find a new custom intent within SiriKit exposed as INObject. This is paired with a full demo app in the form of Soup Chef that shows how you can create these custom intents and use them as shortcuts for Siri Wanna make your own Siri? This is a cool idea, as voice assistants are the best way to improve user experience and increase competitiveness. If you're interested in more detailed information, follow the link and we'll tell you how to integrate Siri into a mobile app or create a voice solution from scratch

SiriKit Tutorial - Right to the Point - Pioneer Mobile Application

Siri shortcuts, a new feature presented at last year's WWDC, offer the ability to perform certain functionalities of the application in the background. We do not have to turn on the application to use these functionalities in the application, we can simply say to Siri, e.g. Burger Time and the system knows to which application this shortcut is assigned and orders a burger for us. Let's say I've defined a custom intent, called FooIntent, in an .intentdefinition file. It has a single parameter, bar, of type Decimal, for which: - User can supply value in Siri and Shortcuts app is active. - Default Value is 0. Its autogenerated class definition now looks like this: public class FooIntent: INIntent { @NSManaged [ Learn iOS - Using Segues (passing data forward) Example. To pass data from the current view controller to the next new view controller (not a previous view controller) using segues, first create a segue with an identifier in the relevant storyboard SiriKit框架解析 ( 三) Sir iShortcuts 开发实践. Dongxk的博客. 08-07. 695. 第 一 步:新建 一 个项目 第二步: 创建Custom Intent 在项目中通过New File. 创建 一 个 Intent s. intent defin it ion文件。. cmd+n 搜索关键字 intent 创建完之后项目中出现. intent defin it ion文件: 第三步. Resolving an intent refers to handling data that is retrieved from Siri from a user's voice. This video shows how to respond when that data is received

Very useful and complete tutorial explaining how to integrate SiriKit in your apps. swift ios extension xcode storage extensions tasks ios-extension ios-app task-list ios-demo task-manager siri sirikit shared-storage. Updated on Mar 24, 2019. Swift What You'll Be Creating Introduction. A lot of articles, our site included, have focused on helping readers create amazing iOS apps by designing a great mobile user experience (UX). However, with the emergence of the Apple Watch a few years ago, alongside CarKit, and more recently the HomePod this year, we are starting to see a lot more apps and IoT appliances that use voice commands instead. ViNiT. Radical Message - Learn to add SiriKit in your messages app. In this tutorial we will learn to implement Siri using Intents in Xcode 8.0 with Swift 3. It can be rated as a beginner level tutorial. Getting started. Open Xcode and create a new project by choosing the Single View Application template. Choose iPhone under Devices SiriKit, the platform that The newest resources go over System Intents, Custom Intents, Shortcuts and Suggestions, reviews, and detailed comparisons and tutorials

In SiriKit, intents have predefined properties that describe the task they belong to. As an example, if a user wants to start a workout, properties will describe the type of exercise and the training length. After receiving the request, the system completes the intent object with specified data and sends it to the app extension Cordova intent url. $ cordova plugin add com.borismus.webintent WebIntent Android Plugin for Cordova 3.X By Boris SmusIn this tutorial, you'll work with an existing web application as you create the client-side Cordova application. You'll start by publishing the web application to the Microsoft Azure App Service,. Build a custom web browser, a local Notepad app, and an iTunes movies browser using iOS 11 and Swift 4 Rating: 4.8 out of 5 4.8 (3 ratings) 24 students Created by Packt Publishing. Published 8/2018 English English [Auto] Add to cart. 30-Day Money-Back Guarantee. Share. What you'll learn The most in-depth Siri course for iOS 12 and Swift 4 development. iOS & Swift: Become An App Developer Devslopes by Mark Wahlbeck, Learn programming & app development Beginner's Guide to Learn iOS, Swift, ARKit, CoreML, App Design, Advanced Programming and Much More $199.99 $139.99 4.1 (1292 ratings) 429 lectures, 90 hours

Note that additional .storekit files can be listed along with the NonConsumables.storekit file, but as I have already mentioned and as you just saw, only one can be active at a time.. Testing In-App Purchases. At this point we are able to test for first time in-app purchases locally. Make sure that you have followed all steps as described in the previous two parts, and then run the app in the. iOS 10 - This article summarizes iOS 10 from Apple, the key developer-related features introduced in iOS 10, which runs on currently shipping iOS devices.The article also lists the documents that describe new features in more detail. iOS 10 SiriKit iOS 10, the Siri iOS 10 Apps that provide services in specific domains can use SiriKit to make those services available from Siri on iOS 10 voltmx.intentExtension Namespace The voltmx.intentExtension namespace provides you with the ability to add Siri-related functionality For more information about what iMessage app extensions are and what you can use them for, refer the Apple developer documentation.. Intent extensions enable your iOS app to interface with Siri

The Intent needs to be eligible for widgets, but Siri Shortcuts and Suggestions are not needed for this. Create a custom intent to allow the user to select a Line for the widget We also need to declare the intent in the application's Info.plist file, otherwise it won't be able to load in the Edit Widget modal Sadly, Siri is not open. We are trying to figure out a way around the sdk to make it work - like many other companies are trying as well. Siri works with the concept of Domains, groups of know actions for related tasks. Each interaction that an app has with Siri must fall into one of its known service Domains as follows · The following Siri courses are available through the learning platform Udemy, which occasionally has huge discounts on courses, some costing less that $10.The courses are often written by industry leaders with real practical experience designing and building the technology, so you get very high quality training from true experts in the field

If you customize the user interface, your Intents UI extension can also configure itself differently, depending on whether the request came from Siri or Maps. To learn how to support SiriKit and give users new ways to access your services, read SiriKit Programming Guide The Intents framework (Intents.framework) supports the handling of SiriKit interactions. IntentsUI The Intents UI framework (IntentsUI.framework) supports the creation of an Intents UI extension, which is an optional app extension that displays custom content in the Siri or Maps interfaces If you customize the user interface, your Intents UI extension can also configure itself differently, depending on whether the request came from Siri or Maps. To learn iOS 10.0 Basic how to support SiriKit and give users new ways to access your services, read SiriKit Programming Guide Intent definition file supports custom validation errors that can be thrown to the system; Contributor comment: Building an intent has 6 steps involved, it's a lot of work, but worth it for pro users; Mac Catalyst apps intents automatically work on Mac, too; Same exact intent definition can be used in both iOS & Mac apps for shared workflow

iOS Applications- How to Ensure an Engaging Customer Journey?. Powerful user acquisition is an essential metric for determinin here, the custom widget view is returned at line 7, which needs to be modified based on the view you want to show in the widget's real estate. the configurationDisplayName and description is shown to the user while he adds widget to his home screen, so you might want to modify that as well. finally, the PreviewProvider struc Accesos directos de Siri en Xamarin.iOS Siri Shortcuts in Xamarin.iOS. 08/08/2018; Tiempo de lectura: 23 minutos; d; o; En este artículo. En iOS 10,Apple introdujo SiriKit, lo que permite crear aplicaciones de mensajería, llamadas VoIP, pagos, viajes, reservas de carreras y búsqueda de fotos que interactúan con Siri. In iOS 10, Apple introduced SiriKit, making it possible to build. Begin your iOS 12 app development journey with this practical guide Key Features Kick-start your iOS programming career and have fun building iOS apps of your choice Get to grips - Selection from iOS 12 Programming for Beginners - Third Edition [Book Apple Embraces Extensions in macOS, iOS 10. At this year's Apple World Wide Developers Conference in San Francisco, one of the underlying themes Apple introduced was the concept of extensions. The goal being to blur the boundaries between apps on the platform, through widgets, but more notably, allowing third-party developers access to many. Python Tutorial: Magic Methods, Previous Chapter: Multiple Inheritance Example The __call__ method enables Python programmers to write classes where the instances to apply the __add __ method from int, which can't cope with Length objects as second arguments! At the very least the rule should be: enum members cannot be overwritten. I prefer to have the rule: enum members cannot overwrite.